BotTalk Reviews

A diva is murdered mid performance.  The Police investigate and Christine, the understudy, struggles with her performance.  A mysterious voice begins to coach her, greatly improving on her abilities.  From the darkness, the Phantom observes her. There is little original here.  This is a story told and retold many times.  In movies, on the stage.  What sets this telling apart from the others is the art.  Beautifully painted by Martin Simmonds.  Full of emotion.  Sadness, frustration, rage, longing.  It remains to be seen how closely this version will follow others.  At this point, I am here for the art.   seven out of ten. 

The Babel conference begins.  Sato addresses the members then it begins to fall apart with shouts and accusations.  After a recess Sato's mentor, Solara, is allowed to speak and suggest founding something called the Emerald Chain.  Meanwhile, a ship at warp approaches.  Once it drops out of warp, it will explode.   This would work better as an episode.  Tense negotiations, backroom dealing.  These make good drama for tv.  In a comic... it is difficult to pull off and keep it compelling.  Kirk has been pushed aside.  You'd think with his experience he would address the delegates at least once.  I appreciate what they are doing here.  And introducing the Emerald Chain is a link to Discovery.  But I found this issue ground things to a halt.   six out of ten.

Archer and Boothby explain once they returned they were considered traitors for suggesting humanity was no threat.  The Doctor infects the 8472 station with nanoprobes. Voyager manages to escape as the 8472 exiles agree to an alliance.  Voyager returns to Earth.  Barclay greets the crew while Hugh greets their Borg allies.  The crew make their reunions.  At a get together the Doctor takes a holophoto of the Voyager crew.   Dr. Katherine Pulaski has a surprising cameo as one of the doctors working to cure Tuvok.  A lot of wrapping up takes place with the crew reuniting with their loved ones.  Chakotay and Seven break up as he confesses he still has feelings for Archer.  Some connective threads relate to Picard, with Seven applying to the Academy, though we know she is rejected.  In a way it feels like Return of the King here, with several long moments wrapping up our characters.  It is certainly more satisfying than what we got in th...

A family argument breaks out on a rented houseboat.  Chet and his sister Laura take shots and jabs at each other, each placing blame on the other.  The next day it continues until Laura and her husband cannonball into the water.  The husband comes back for his brother-in-law.  Chet dives in only to come up in a darker version of reality, while his sister and brother-in-law find a somewhat nicer reality.  Chet's new friends turn on him.  At the same time, his sister realizes she wouldn't trade the slightly nicer world for her brother.  She dives in to save him, comes back up only to smack into the false bottom of the boat.  Looking down at her is Chet, unable to break through to her. In a way this feels like a take on 'The Bewitchin' Pool' the final episode of the original series.  Only here we get a better world and its shadow.  Honestly, the dialogue between Chet and Laura is insufferable.  It feels very of the moment and just goes...

The Omega will soon head out toward Babel.  A conference will determine the future of the Federation, the trip will take the Omega four months... but everyone else, twenty three years.  Before they leave First Officer 'Wowie' has a disappointing family reunion.  He returns over the years and time moves on.  His family grows bitter, Earth slowly recovers but the future appears bleak.  Wowie returns to the Omega and says that Kirk should be in charge. The situation on Earth, at least the political climate, feels very 'of the moment'.  We see those who lived in comfort now living with fear.  This issue is focused on 'Wowie'.  we get to see his family life, his personal doubts, and how he sticks to his guns in the face of opposition from his family and others.   seven out of ten.

Chapel reunites with her friend, no longer under control of the Seed.  In space the Enterprise is intertwined in vines.  Pike confronts the Seed controlled Una.  He manages to speak directly to the Seed, informing them their jailers are long gone.  Enterprise fires a beam at the surface that frees the trapped prison ship.  Later, Chapel and Una beam down to a 'boring' planet with The Seed, presenting them with a new home. I feel like this five issue mini is the first or second draft of a Strange New Worlds episode.  There are some interesting ideas, with an unusual setting.  But as I have said there is something lacking in its portrayal of our characters.  Scotty especially, but even the modern take on Chapel feels off in this series.  The resolution is very Trek.  Talking with the Seed and resolving the situation.  Much appreciated as opposed to a pew pew sfx battle.   six out of ten.  

Species 8472 chase Voyager as the Doctor attempts to make more nanoprobes.  Janeway has Voyager take a hit from the Borg cube, defending their new allies against 8472.  As reinforcements come in, Voyager takes out three bioships.  The assault against the ship intensifies.  The planet killer beam is charged and fired on the Borg cube, with Seven and her new allies beamed away at the last moment.  Janeway surrenders when 8472 promises the Voyager crew will live.  They are taken to a base where they meet Boothby and Archer... and Admiral Paris. A lot going on this issue and it feels intense.  The Doctor struggles to produce new assimilation nanoprobes while under attack and dealing with the ailing Tuvok.  I will say the Borg who were severed from the Collective get little to do here except dodge weapons fire.  The appearance of 'Boothby' and Archer from an episode of Voyager is much appreciated.   seven out of ten.

In a medieval setting a fortress is under siege.  During the attack an armoured knight opens the gates and stands ready with a modern gun.  He opens fire.  In conflict with the leader of the opposition the knight is defeated by his own weapons and the victors enter the fort.  Behind enormous doors we see a tank, a WWII plane and seemingly an atomic bomb.  The victor meets the face of God, a fast food drive through character with a speaker in its stomach.   The art for this issue is great.  The story, however... just doesn't fit The Twilight Zone.  I could see it in Eerie (1966 Warren Magazine) or Creepy (1964 Warren Magazine), but it just doesn't have that 'it' factor that says The Twilight Zone.  That doesn't mean it is bad.  Not at all.  It is a fine story.  I just think that it would fit in better elsewhere.   six out of ten.

Sato gives Kirk command of the Omega and he immediately springs into action, giving various orders.  The Omega speeds back to Earth only to find it has been bombarded by the Warp Cores from the Klingon Fleet.  Sato challenges the Klingon Fleet Commander to single combat.  He eventually defeats his opponent and sends the Klingons to their death while Kirk questions Agnes.  Earth, having been devastated, breaks aways from the Federation and is now an independent world.   The distinction between Sato and Kirk is further displayed here.  Kirk jumps into action, giving orders the moment he is given command.  Sato hesitates at the very idea of bloodshed but ultimately, kills the Klingon Commander and later, spills even more blood.  The last panel is... certainly something.  Nothing I expected.  Given that the Klingon situation has been resolved and Earth has declared independence I wonder where the story goes from here.   seven out of ten...

In space the Enterprise is pummelled by the drones but Uhura manages to send out a signal.  The drones begin to target each other.  On the planet Spock, Scotty and D-6 sink further underwater and discover a plant enveloped spaceship while Chapel battles The Seed.  Spock mind melds with a giant octopus that gives the backstory of The Seed.  Chapel is beaten and imprisoned as The Seed prison ship rises from the depths to confront the Enterprise, with a possessed Una in command. This is the most interesting issue of Seeds of Salvation thus far.  D-6 continues to feel like an annoying Star Wars character, making wisecracks constantly.  We get a callback to better Trek with Spock mind melding with a non-humanoid lifeform here.  The Seed backstory is unremarkable really.  The stakes were raised this issue on multiple fronts though.     six out of ten.

Raad manages to sow some discontent between the Klingons and Romulans.  She challenges the Romulan commander to single combat.  When it appears she has the upper hand Miller takes a disruptor and kills her.  He is actually a Romulan agent.  The Klingons get the data they were promised, but are destroyed by the Romulans.  Miller is eventually rescued by the Enterprise and names Raad as the spy. This final issue stinks.  The single combat sequence is built up only for it to be rendered useless by the reveal of Miller being a spy.  This completely falls flat for me.  It doesn't make me want to go back and reread the previous issues for clues.  It just makes me want to forget about this entire mini series.  The promise of a mini devoted to no-name red shirts getting killed off was interesting, but it was a complete letdown.  And I say that as someone who enjoys horror films, there were one or two interesting kills.  But it all just...

Three months pass and Dr. Jack Griffin lives with the fear that Tommy, his escaped ward, may come back and kill him.  He halts the experiments and tries to be patient.  One day a note arrives from Tommy, stating he will take everything from him.  But the invisible boy walks through flour and strangles a dummy.  Griffin is now invisible too and takes care of him, leaving his body in the snow.  With his death he becomes visible and is discovered.  Griffin leaves everyone and everything behind, takes a room far away at The Lion's Head inn and begins work on finding a cure. Having Griffin live in fear of the young Tommy was a nice way to turn the tables.  He thought to simply be patient and things would go back to normal, but for him that was never in the cards.  Griffin is not a man we can sympathize with.  Like any good villain, you can only go so far in understanding his side.  Ultimately, this comic ends where the original Universal 1933...

Kathryn Janeway and the rest manage to escape from Species 8472 in a shuttle and head back to Voyager.  They find a cave and decide to hide so a new deflector can be built.  Sending out a probe, they find wreckage from a Borg cube, destroyed during the invasion of  several years ago.  Seven discovers Borg drones, cut off from the Collective, who have a working deflector.  8472 make contact with Janeway.  They want the deflector.  Janeway can either ally with them, or the Borg... The Borg drones who survived the 8472/Borg war and just happen to have a working deflector is very convenient.  At least they remembered Voyager's upgrades provided by Future Janeway.  This issue moves at a fairly brisk pace, only giving us a few pages to spend time with The Doctor and Tuvok.  It does give the feeling of a Voyager season finale though.   seven out of ten. 

A crew in cryosleep wakes up and eventually begins the explore a planet.  As they talk the things they mention seemingly appear, although alien and distorted in nature.  Eventually they come upon two lifeforms, one beating the other.  One of the crew intervenes and they are soon overwhelmed by aliens and taken into custody.  Placed in a holding cell they attack the wall and it reacts.  They escape and eventually the real aliens show themselves.  They state that the planet can read their minds, that the planet is for relaxation and therapy.  They offer to start over and go through a reconfigured therapy but it will take centuries.  The crew, except for one, agree.  Alone, he returns to Earth but those in charge refuse to believe his story. In every aspect this has the feel of the original Twilight Zone.  The black and white art.  The designs of the space suits and spaceship.  The aliens.  The ending.  I expected nothin...

James T. Kirk and Captain Sato discuss classic literature while the command crew arrives.  They make final preparations to engage Transwarp drive when a fleet of Klingon ships are detected.  The Borg-enhanced Omega arrives and immediately comes under attack.  As the Omega fights for its life Kirk begins to flashback to the death of his son (David Marcus in Star Trek III: The Search for Spock).  As a Klingon boarding party breaches the hull Kirk appears on the bridge, reporting for duty and wearing a Starfleet uniform. We see the polarity between a resurrected Kirk and Sato, his modern counterpart.  Sato knows little of war while Kirk is more than experienced, Sato even giving Kirk a specific number of people who died as a result of orders he gave.  We get some time with the crew of the Omega... but not much.  A few even appear to have been killed off during the battle.  This is still the most engaged, to pardon a pun, I've felt with an IDW Trek c...

As the landing party tries to avoid The Seed they become separated.  Spock and D-6 encounter Scotty and the trio manage to escape in a mini sub as the underwater complex is destroyed.  Underground, Chapel comes face to face with La'an Noonien-Singh and Number One, now possessed by The Seed.   Again, a lot going on this issue... and again, very little seems to happen.  The cliffhanger of the Enterprise being surrounded is followed up on by only a few pages.  The action of this issue is focused on the surface, with Chapel having several conversations with her old friend, now possessed by The Seed.  It is the old routine of a friend telling someone things they don't want to hear or don't want to admit.  Seen it before a thousand times.  D-6 continues to feel like a Star Wars character and Scotty hardly registers to me as actually acting like Scotty. six out of ten.

The Klingons torture the captured Starfleet personnel while, in space, they face off against the Romulans.  Neither willing to make the first move.  On the surface the trapped personnel manage to raise the buried ship from the swamp and blast off.  The captured Starfleet crew turn the tide on their captors and escape.  The buried ship is eventually destroyed by the Romulans and later the Klingons and Romulans agree to meet, and the Romulans ask them to bring the recaptured Starfleet personnel with them.   This issue was better than the previous ones.  The stakes feel higher with Klingons and Romulans getting involved.  Red shirt crew continue to get killed off though, and two are tortured by the Klingons with painstiks.  Honestly, I was expecting more gore once the Klingons showed up, but that was not the case. six out of ten.

The Voyager crew meet in sickbay and discuss the situation.  Part of the command crew attempt to retake Main Engineering.  B'Elanna Torres hits a plasma conduit that should disintegrate Species 8472 on contact, but fails.  8472 destroy the main deflector, rendering Voyager unable to open a rift back home.  The team surrenders and, leaving Seven of Nine behind, are taken to meet the Hierarch of Species 8472.  Kathryn Janeway's meeting does not go well and after B'Elanna finds the data they need to open a rift home Janeway tells her to delete it. Species 8472 kinda has a point here.  Janeway aided the Borg in their conflict.  They didn't follow First Contact procedures.  They also never bothered to learn their real name, they just continue to use the Borg designation.  This issue feels somewhat rushed but it does make Species 8472 seem as threatening as they were during their first appearance.  Though, you would think they would have more...

The experiments continue.  Dr. Jack Griffin takes a room in an unsavoury part of town and tests the invisibility serum on a boy living on the streets.  Instead of complete invisibility it simply makes his outer layer of skin disappear.  After months he is reduced to a living skeleton and finally, a pair of eyes that seemingly float in the air.  Finally achieving total invisibility the street urchin knocks Jack unconscious and escapes.   Again the theme of feeling like an outcast in society, invisible to the upper class, is present.  Jack spends much time simply sitting and trying to be invisible in public places by simply not moving, not drawing attention to himself.  The pressure continues to mount though, as his fiancé seems to find his increasing absence, attention lacking and his boss demanding to see results.  Going from animals to humans for experimentation is a logical step.  We shall see how the newly invisible Tommy uses his ability...

The submarine crew manage to escape from 'squid thingies' and enter some sort of underwater structure.  Making their way inside they encounter people covered in strange vines until they discover Christine Chapel's friend, Jinare, covered in the same vines and seemingly possessed by some entity.  In orbit, Nyota Uhura manages to decipher an ancient symbol.  It states the planet is a prison for the entity.  It then detects the Enterprise and sends multiple ships to intercept.  The robot, D-6... is annoying.  It feels like a character from a completely different show... like a Marvel character... full of quips that are supposed to be funny or endearing but fall flat.  Our actual Star Trek characters also feel off... like they were written by someone who has only seen a handful of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds episodes.  Scotty especially feels very ADHD. five out of ten.